Senft et al: They’re Eating the Pets

Abstract

This article develops a conceptual framework for understanding how social media platforms engineer laughter as a stimulus within digital attention economies. Moving beyond interpretations of laughter as a secondary emotional response, we argue it functions as a platform-designed affective mechanism—bodily, social, and economic—intended to drive user engagement, amplify algorithmic visibility, and monetize participation. We introduce the concept of franchised laughter to describe how platforms transform laughter into a measurable and monetizable signal, operationalized through datafication, algorithmic curation, and emotional AI systems that detect, classify, and predict user responses. Historically connective, laughter now circulates as part of persuasive computing infrastructures that incentivize interaction and sustain the creator economy. These infrastructures rely on automated emotion recognition, UX design strategies, and affective analytics to convert emotion into actionable metrics, shaping recommendation systems, engagement loops, and platform governance. This shift challenges human-centric models of online behaviour and calls for a structural understanding of how platforms engineer and exploit emotional responses. We argue that the franchising logic underpinning these processes has profound implications for platform power, political discourse, and the circulation of misinformation. To illustrate these dynamics, we analyse the viral meme cycle “They’re Eating the Pets”, which originated during the ABC News U.S. Presidential Debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris and evolved into a case study of algorithmically amplified humour, affective contagion, and platform-driven engagement.

Keywords

franchised laughter, social media platforms, emotional AI, attention economy, creator economy, datafication, online humour

For the official version of record, see here:

Senft, T. M., Müller, C. J., & Nickl, B. (2026). They’re Eating the Pets: Social Media Platforms & the Stimulation of Franchised Laughter. Media Theory, 10(1), 149–180. https://doi.org/10.70064/mt.v10i1.1371

They’re Eating the Pets: Social Media Platforms & the Stimulation of Franchised Laughter

THERESA M. SENFT
University of Turku, FINLAND

CHRISTOPHER JOHN MÜLLER
Macquarie University, AUSTRALIA

BENJAMIN NICKL
The University of Sydney, AUSTRALIA

Introduction

In 1999, Time magazine called the television laugh track, ‘one of the hundred worst ideas of the twentieth century’ (36), but the worst for whom? Perhaps only for the audience, who suddenly found themselves artificially stimulated in a new way, but certainly not for the industry that developed this technology to make its shows more engaging. In the same vein, imagine if one day your social media feed—the same one you check to keep up with news, relax, zone out, gossip, and perhaps learn a thing or two—appeared entirely free of memes, LOLs, laugh-cry emojis, or other pleasantly reassuring feedback cues encouraging you to join in and laugh along. The technologization of laughter that here comes into sight seems primed with one intent: don’t stop being engaged, don’t switch off, don’t stop laughing, don’t ever stop feeling like you are ‘doing’ something.

In this article, we advance a conceptual mapping of the highly ambiguous role laughter plays as a generator, arbitrator, and distributor of machine-human interactions on social media platforms. Laughter—stimulating by being alternately shocking, cute, endearing, outrageous, or otherwise bodily captivating—is currently a mainstay feature of an economic model that ‘defines attention as a scarce but quantifiable commodity’ (Crogan and Kinsley, 2012: 1). Undergirding this model lies a central claim: that digital platforms have the capacity to detect and quantify on-site human behaviour adequately enough to (1) design personalization algorithms that keep users coming back for more, and (2) repackage that quantification into visual and narrative formats like analytic dashboards and ‘insights’ reports designed to satisfy the interests of advertisers, who constitute more than 90% of platform revenue streams (McStay, 2021). Positioned within business models that aim to measure and market human emotion via metrics like screen ‘dwell time,’ link click-throughs, and user habits, the bodily dynamics of laughter take on a special significance that this article seeks to map.

While there is a large body of work on the strategic uses and potentials of (online)humour in political, marketing or participatory contexts (see for instance, Ahmed, 2014; Morreall, 2009; Shifman, 2014; Sundén & Paasonen, 2020; Weinberger & Gulas, 2019), we consider the platformed nature and stimulating force of online laughter within and against the ‘attention economy’ model, beginning with three claims. First, it has never been possible to assess what laughter is, means, or does, without considering power. Second, in social media contexts, the power to circulate laughter and other ‘emotions on the move’ (Boler & Davis, 2020) rests with the platform first, users second. One upshot of this is that today, ‘anyone can discover they have inadvertently circulated misinformation online,’ not due to the quality of the content, but ‘because platforms frequently leave us too emotionally overstimulated to do otherwise’ (Senft, 2025). Third, in the lived experience of users, the monolith known as ‘the platform’ does not actually exist. Indeed, the so-called ‘creator economy’ (Peres et al, 2024) turns on the argument that in a competitive marketplace, brand loyalty requires incentivizing platform users of all stripes; hence the concurrent rise of both monetization-focused ‘creator studios’, and badges for ‘unbroken streaks’ of app engagement. Resting within an economic model that conceives of attention as an extractable source of value and platform integration as vertical, the creator economy moves users horizontally within and across platforms in ways that make it increasingly difficult to say for sure who is producer, who is consumer, and who makes up the public within which an affective interaction or specific instance of humour traverses.[i]

The conceptual mapping we advance suggests that digital platforms are configured to turn laughter into a stimulus both in the bodily and economic sense: they ‘excite’, ‘incentivize’ and ‘increase’ user activity and engagement (OED: stimulus) in hopes of converting these into data that can be tracked and sold to off-platform buyers looking for target markets for advertising. It is for this reason we name platformed laughter as franchised laughter. Here, we seek to foreground a dimension of human-machine interaction that user-centric models struggle to account for: if laughter has always been the connective tissue of human groups, then digital platforms have not invented (or fundamentally altered) this affective stimulus; rather, they have developed new modalities of measuring, modulating and monetizing it, with attendant knock-on effects in realms like politics, cultural exchange and everyday interaction, online and off. 

Legally, franchising is the practice of licensing rights to use a concrete asset one owns, usually a proven business system, and/or branding materials. While emotions themselves cannot be franchised, much franchising turns on the argument that successful companies have developed replicable but proprietary systems to elicit desired emotions (e.g. Disney and “childhood wonder”) and the promise that with proper adherence, these systems can be used to help others achieve similar results. In the pages that follow, we argue that branded platforms offer a similar proposition to users hoping to profit from their time online, whether they understand this as monetizing content, socially ‘making it’ among peers, or receiving exposure to things they want to see. The proposition: if you want to experience or offer emotions associated with enfranchisement (e.g., recognition, significance, esteem, belonging) you must first serve as a franchise willing to adopt, promote, and enforce platform-specific logics—ideally, in ways that make it difficult for others to determine where your personal style ends and platform adherence begins.

A paradox regarding laughter on platforms is that a collective resource and mechanism for human survival now circulates as economic stimulus, accruing value for infrastructures capturing it first, and communities it is meant to sustain second. To map the political dimensions of this paradox, we discuss a particularly ‘overstimulating’ meme and content cycle popularly shorthanded as ‘They’re Eating the Pets’ (hereafter TETP). Its origins can be found in a live exchange between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris during the ABC News US Presidential Debates, watched on television by more than 67 million viewers on 10 September 2024 (Hoffman, 2024). Seemingly in response to questions about immigration policy, Trump shared a ‘bizarre and debunked conspiracy theory’ that Haitian immigrants in the city of Springfield Illinois were currently ‘eating people’s pets’ (Anderson, 2024). Across the television’s split screen, viewers watched how Kamala Harris (later accused by Trump of ‘baiting’ his response) burst into incredulous laughter.

The Presidential Debate has a complex online backstory,[ii] but as an online event, ‘they’re eating the pets’ arguably begins with the closeup shots of Harris’s face, the joke being that she was reacting to an incendiary political attack made during a televised debate with the bemused laughter of someone watching a news-spoof at home. Among those who were watching live, her laughter seemed to stimulate a range of online behaviours ranging from verbal agreement to visual mimicry. Using platform affordances, users quickly began pasting Harris reaction shots into their own posts. Some were about Trump, as in, ‘Same, Kamala, same’ (Gosh, 2024.) Many were on unrelated topics, such as, ‘When my student says he did not use Chat GTP,’ redirecting the original stimulus to users’ own ends. Next, users began flooding social platforms with reaction shots of themselves and their pets reacting to news they might be next on the menu (Olmstead, 2024), with camera-shy posts getting in on the fun by posting updates like ‘marked safe from having my pet eaten,’ later available on t-shirts (MARdStoreCo, 2024).

Figure 1: Reactions. References: Marked Safe (MARdStoreCo, 2024); Same (Gosh, 2024); Dogs at Home (ET Online News, 2024)

To anchor our conceptualisation of franchised laughter, we developed an informal working taxonomy, including categories such as reactions, references, hijacking, remixes, performances, AI imaginings, amongst others. These highly diverse formats point to what Ryan Milner calls ‘polyvocal public participation’: they exemplify an event in which many voices are ‘connecting and conversing’ as well as ‘arguing and antagonizing’ (Milner, 2016: 112), and they do so within a platformed environment that provides a wide range of tools and technological affordances that are designed to stimulate such participation. This creative outburst is thus not just a spontaneous moment of affective contagion; it is facilitated by a technological infrastructure that encourages creation of shareable “canned” laughter-as-content, outsourcing what used to be the work of the studio laugh-track to users themselves. As our taxonomy reveals, polyvocal here also means poly-risible, as the formats, each in their own way seek to channel and provoke different types of laughter to many different ends, whilst also tapping into and amplifying one of the best documented functions of humour: inclusion and exclusion in and across various communities (Davies, 1982; Boxer & Cortés-Conde, 1997; Mullan, 2022).

Figure 2: Taxonomy of Responses. Image by Theresa M. Senft

This leads us back to the highly ambiguous role laughter plays as a generator, arbitrator and distributor of machine-human interactions on digital platforms. Commenting on the playful TETP trope, Whitney Philips reminds us that all engagement reinforces the original incendiary gesture, even if it seeks to deride Trump and the MAGA crowd. As she puts it, ‘When you’re making a joke using the frame of immigrants as cultural invaders, even if you’re pushing back on it, the frame is still amplified’ (Oremus, 2024). In this warning, ethical agency seems to be assigned solely to platform users, implicitly asked not to participate so as not to drive engagement–even if that engagement is driven by the ethical motivation of pushing back. But what of the platform designed to amplify content, and thus the frame?

It is here that we locate the conceptual gap that we seek to map, since such human-centric framings of laughter are in danger of deflecting from the central role of platforms in modulating, incentivising and disseminating laughter. In social media contexts, laughter is at once situationally (and thus ethically) specific, and the result and driver of coordinated and black-boxed processes of datafication users can at best intuit. 

We began this article with a promise to map the role laughter plays on social media platforms, starting from the charge that to understand laughter, we need to understand power, including its perceptions and imaginings. We define power as the ability to do something, including the capacity to affect someone or something, also known as influence. While tempted to focus immediately on the ‘someone and something’ represented in our politically charged case study, we will delay until we have adequately addressed our second axiom: in social media environments, the first place to look for power is the platform.

Laughter, power, platforms: Datafication and the emergence of emotional AI

Laughter has a set of characteristics uniquely suited to facilitate online engagement and interaction, which itself relies on the interaction with technological systems that are designed to feel intuitive and easy and fun to use (Nickl and Müller, 2023). These systems thus depend both on their users’ active engagement and interaction, whilst also requiring users to accept and continually adapt to ever-changing interfaces and platform affordances (see Chun, 2017).

It is here that cognitive science and the phenomenology of laughter can foreground how digital platforms seem increasingly designed to incentivize, direct, and modulate this bodily response. On one level, laughter has an ‘eruptive’ quality—it is an internal stimulus that takes hold of us even when we do not express it (Plessner, 2020: 23). At the same time, it nevertheless becomes manifest as something that we tend to voluntarily ‘do’ as ‘an intentional, communicative act’ (Scott et al, 2014: 618).

This paradoxical quality of being something that happens to us while being experienced as something that is done by us is what distinguishes laughter from other sorts of bodily affect like anger or shame (Plessner, 2020: 24). Whereas these can overpower our intentions and make us lose composure, laughter seems to afford distance, a sense of orientation and a readiness to engage. As such, its highly contagious and reactive nature is nevertheless not experienced as a loss of autonomy, and Plessner especially links it to situations that are experienced as ‘in suspension’ because they depend on ‘our creative readiness and power’ (76). In other words, it is a prime mediator of play and social exchange. It establishes a sense of ease, in which we can enjoy how we are ‘both master and not yet master’ of a situation we are part of but ‘without becoming so firmly established that individual choice is completely lost’ (77).

Like the meme-format itself, which, as Milner notes, channels ‘“the eternal tension between fixity and novelty that constitutes creativity”’ (Tannen, [1989] 2007: 29 cited in Milner, 2016: 95), design solutions such as graphic user interfaces, inboxes, news feeds and recommendation devices embody this very logic. They create realities that, in Plessner’s words, are permanently ‘in suspension’ and thereby also incentivise and invite ‘our creative readiness and power’. The past decade has seen an explosion of templates, meme-maker toolkits, reel and temporary message formats, filters, and other digital tools testifying to the success of design efforts to intensify users’ creative play and sense of being at ease by reducing entry-level friction at the platform’s interface. 

Additionally, laughter is behaviourally highly contagious and has an especially important role in social interactions and communication, where it often signals affirmation and facilitates social bonds (Scott et al, 2014). Indeed, there are fewer things more reassuring to a person who signs off with a laugh than to receive one in return—a psychological fact featuring heavily in the techno-social discussion to follow, where we demonstrate that of all emotions, laughter is best suited to technological systems designed to ‘drag’ users along and ‘suck their attention’ into the screen, whilst simultaneously facilitating an (often illusory) sense of connection, autonomy, distance and user-control. As such, its soothing, smoothing, humanising, pro-social and in- and out-group qualities are valued not only by users and creators, but also in the context of user-experience design and recommendation systems (see Nickl and Müller, 2023).

In a landscape in which ‘capturing users’ attention is becoming increasingly challenging’, as a blog by a UX design studio notes, ‘humour emerges as a powerful, yet often underappreciated, tool’. It is said to ‘trigger [the] release of endorphins, the body’s feel-good chemicals,’ and the blog goes on to market design solutions that can harness such anaesthetic boosts for a wide array of client interests and needs. Laughter is said to foster ‘brand loyalty’, improve ‘user retention rates’, make engagements ‘more memorable’, all the while affording (what the language of UX design terms) a ‘cognitive break,’ a primed ‘moment of mental relaxation that can reduce stress and frustration’ (Demirtaş, 2023).

The framing of laughter that is set out in this promotional blog can help introduce the current trajectories of platform ecologies we are seeking to conceptualise and map. Rather than being framed through paradigms such as usability, functionality, user safety and accessibility, digital media are here introduced as ways to manage, activate, instrumentalise and monetize their users’ capacities to feel. The situation portrayed is one in which prompted or algorithmically primed laughter, amusement or ‘emotional engagement’ are hoped to affect a buy in that might align a user to a specific goal or perspective (the content level) whilst also ensuring that they keep on using and interacting with a given platform and device (the UX level). We borrow this term from McKelvey et al who describe this exercise as simultaneously economic and libidinal, noting that buy-in involves ‘belief, excitement, and even willingness to participate even when “a true believer is indistinguishable from a shill”’ (Swartz, 2022: 1707 in McKelvey et al, 2023).

In the current economic model, it is thus no longer just attention in the form of screen time but its modulation through the stimulation of specifiable feelings that platforms promise to deliver, thereby giving ‘emotional life economic value’: ‘If one can affect emotion and make people feel a certain way,’ as Andrew McStay explains, ‘an organisation has an increased chance of capturing attention, making a desired impression and affecting decision making’ (McStay, 2018: 17). Viewed from this perspective, ‘influence’ means the ability to play a part in shaping feelings, attitudes, behaviours and actions. Whereas this has always been a prime goal of strategic communication (be it through advertising, education, or political rhetoric), a defining trait of the so-called ‘attention economy’, as mentioned earlier, is the ability of digital platforms to create real-time ‘insights’ that purport to quantify user behaviour and, increasingly, emotion.

Although emotions are extensively studied across a wide range of disciplines (e.g. neuroscience, psychology, evolutionary biology, philosophy, cultural studies), there is ‘no consensus’ about ‘what emotions are’ (Scarantino, 2016: 37, cited in McStay, 2023: 23). As McStay has demonstrated in his mapping of this rapidly growing industry, developers tend to revert to the definitions and interpretive frameworks that best map onto the technological parameters and available data sets (McStay, 2018). Technologies that are able to detect heart rate will have a different way of decoding emotion to technologies that seek to track facial expression or process language. Yet despite this diversity, McStay cites the view of a Chief Insights Officer at a media agency to introduce the basic ‘truism’ driving innovation in this field: ‘people are not to be relied upon to say what they really think or feel’; that is to say, ‘observing’ and inferring emotion and sentiments is deemed more conclusive than asking someone what they want, like or how they feel (McStay, 2018: 116).

How, then, does laughter fit into this complex picture? It is readily apparent that secretly observing how people interact with a constant stream of potentially funny prompts is likely to yield a very different outcome than the kind of answer they might provide when interviewed about their humour preferences. It is likewise apparent that algorithmically mapping, incentivising and pushing content tagged as engaging through immediate interaction will lead to a very different, much more stimulating feed than one that would be attained by means of a focus group. In fact, as ‘people often say humorously what they would never dare say blankly’ (Shifman & Blondheim, 2010: 1349), humorous content is often itself construed as a means to peek behind the social mask. It is here, however, that McStay also locates the key challenge these technologies represent: ‘The task for all stakeholders is to find appropriate means of living with emotion-capture technologies in a way that respects the dignity of human life, rather than approaches that treat people as emotional animals to be biomedically mapped and manipulated’ (2018: 169). If this is to be achieved, the paradoxical and complex nature of laughter’s relationship to the creation, consumption and circulation of online content needs to be better understood.

In terms of its practical application in the social media platforms that are our focus in this article, Senft (2025) isolates automated emotion recognition (AER), sentiment analysis, and persuasive computing as the three most popular technologies that are currently used to track, analyse and market feeling through the ‘insights’ and ‘dashboards’ that platforms make available. Yet in the context of a special issue on media stimulation, the dynamics of persuasive computing—and especially the dynamic of algorithmically curated and incentivised content in news feeds, such as ‘For You pages’—are of special significance. When approached through the lens of Plessner’s discussion of laughter, these design solutions are ways to artificially create suspense and ambiguity, creating a condition in which, to borrow words by Plessner, ‘things can surprise us by their appearance, take an unforeseen turn, or create situations to which we can no longer find a serious response’. In short, they create situations in which we can find things ‘funny’ in a way that invites us to engage (see Plessner, 2020: 92).

We mobilize Plessner’s phenomenological perspective because it adds an important caveat to the ‘stimulus variable response’ models that dominate the discussion of news feeds. Their design is often attributed to the Skinner box, an experimental device with which psychologist BF Skinner sought to establish whether rats and other lab animals would adapt their behaviour more quickly if ‘food rewards came predictably, or if they were meted out randomly’ (Kuang & Fabricant, 2019: 253; see also Stöcker, 2020 or Lanier, 2018). Against Skinner’s expectation, it was not the predictable but the variable reward that resulted in the more profound behavioural changes, a reinforcement effect that is linked to the release of dopamine that coincides with surprise reward. As this principle was directly applied to addictive technologies such as slot machines (Schüll, 2014), Kuang introduces today’s Skinner boxes through the ‘brand names’ of digital platforms (‘Facebook’, ‘Instagram’, ‘Gmail’, ‘Twitter’) as these platforms are all built around their own version of a ‘pull-to-refresh gesture’ that lets new content appear (Kuang & Fabricant, 2019: 257).[i]

Yet what the somewhat one-dimensional (if popular) fixation on dopamine, addiction and Skinner boxes misses, is the way in which laughter and humour complexify this image of techno-determinism (Nickl, 2024). The persuaded are not simply coerced through addiction but are stimulated through the provision of a stream of always refreshed content. Viewed through the lens of Plessner, each message, post or item of content represents a ‘situation,’ calling on us to engage or voluntarily respond with a laugh (e.g. a ‘lol’ or haha emoticon) as part of a highly specific act of communication and social affirmation. The stimulus—and such is the magic of the ‘powerful, yet underappreciated tool’ (Demirtaş, 2023) called humour—can feel like the beginning of an autonomous and freely given response. As we laugh and express ourselves online, we help platforms identify content that might resonate with us and others, thereby helping to stimulate others and increasing engagement. While still keeping users highly regulated and fixed, consumption thus converts into an experience that feels like voluntary participation and creativity.

When datafication meets the creator economy: From they’re eating to you ate

What began as mass media’s ‘electrification of attention’ (Citton, 2017: 63)—exemplified by stimulation technologies like the laugh track and other forms of ‘reaction engineering’ (Giotta, 2017: 338-339)—has evolved into a system capable of converting world events into multiple, often radically incommensurate personalized feeds that can sufficiently motivate users to engage in creative practices that can produce laughter and social affirmation for others. This segmentation is in itself aided by the in- outgroup qualities of laughter, which can facilitate a sense of community, parasocial connection and automatic affirmation—there is an impulse to return a smile, even if it is seen only on a screen.

In the previous pages, we have discussed how emotion in general—and laughter in particular—has come to be conceptualized as a quantifiable and marketable source of value through a range of practices collectively known as datafication. In the pages that follow, we consider these in the context of the so-called creator economy on social media platforms.

We begin our discussion of the meme-cycle TETP by underscoring a material fact about platforms and making a phenomenological claim about creativity. First, all social media sites treat one another as market competition, including those owned by the same parent company, including state-sponsored platforms operating in places like China. Secondly, like laughter, creativity—the emotional fuel driving the production and circulation of content online—tends to operate best in platformed environments where (1) users perceive themselves to be safe, and (2) the slide between doer and done to is relatively friction-free and (3) that slide is actively encouraged by others.

To guide our discussion, we here include a diagram of ‘Creator Economy Processes’. It provides a schematic overview of how lived experience (of ideas, emotions, feelings, states) is turned into the stuff of digital content and circulated in the name of creative participation. From a platform perspective, the most vulnerable moment in this model occurs at its start, which is why so many apps offer interfaces that make it as easy as possible to create and publish content and produce reactions. Without these, it would be impossible to initiate a stimulus response loop in which the roles of creator and user /viewer/reader/consumer are deliberately blurred.

Figure 3: The Creator Economy Processes. Image created by Theresa Senft

Having provided a brief overview of the processes driving the Creator Economy, we are ready to apply it to the case study with which we began our article. Having discussed earlier the reactions of Kamala Harris and others, we will focus here on creative reworkings of Trump’s words: ‘In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs. The people that came in. They’re eating the cats. They’re eating–they’re eating the pets of the people that live there. And this is what’s happening in our country. And it’s a shame.’

In their overview of online humour, Leneiste (2024) distinguishes between spontaneous humour spread via interactions among users, and laughs generated in response to jokes found in ‘canned’ material circulating online. Dominating this latter category on platforms are memes, news spoofs, and audiovisual clips that lend themselves to remixes and performance-oriented online challenges, all of which featured in the cycle discussed below.

Figure 4: Referencings: Sign Guy Meme & Gordon Ramsey Meme (Phil, 2024); Bart Simpson Meme (ET Online News, 2024); Alf Meme (Yahoo News, 2024).

As a form of entertainment, a major selling point of TETP was how quickly it could be converted into content allowing users to accrue cultural, social, symbolic and sometimes economic capital. Much of this happened through intertextual referencing. For example, almost immediately after Springfield was mentioned in the debate, users began circulating images related to the American television shows The Simpsons and ALF. For some, creation in this context was as simple as posting with a screen shot from Google Images, or a reaction from GIPHY. For others, it involved transferring that image into a template to generate a meme, or else being the first to pass an existing meme to one’s social circle. For still others, it involved sharing the knowledge that Springfield, Illinois is where the Simpsons are supposed to live, or that Alf is supposed to be an alien with an irrepressible extraterrestrial appetite for eating the family cat. Those unfamiliar with American TV might choose instead to work with templates of memes known internationally. English language versions we spotted included Sign Guy silently announcing, ‘Do Not Take Your Pets to Springfield’, as well as the well-known meme featuring television chef Gordon Ramsey calling a cat ‘a Haitian Sandwich.’

Figure 5: Hijackings: The Wiener Circle Meme & Patriots Meme (Phil, 2024); Diseases you Can Get from Eating Dogs/Cats (Figura, 2024).
Figure 6: Remixes &Performances. Ringtone (Benzilla2000, 2024); Roblox (Mariton, 2024). Christopher Tester Meme (ET Online News, 2024); Dance Challenge (Katz, 2024); Kiffness Still (WineRev, 2024).

Five years ago, it used to be common to see posts in online forums to the effect of ‘I’m going to steal your meme but leave a thank you.’ The now-tired joke is that memes cannot be stolen, because they cannot be owned—but they can arguably be hijacked for the attention they bring in the moment, as we saw when losing football team Cincinnati Bengals posted, ‘They are killing our cats in Ohio,’ when a local eatery featured a sign reading, ‘Immigrants eat hot dogs,’ and  when a veterinarian decided her TikTok should cover diseases you can get from eating dogs and cats. This hijacking points to the increasingly platformed dimensions of laughter and emotion evident in practices such as stitching, remixing and challenges that hinge on ‘the creative readiness’ of its participants.

For musicians, comics, and dancers looking to get noticed online, Trump’s lines offered a soundscape that was ripe for remixing into dramatic monologues and musical compositions that lent themselves to live performance. These in turn kicked off a number of dance challenges that could and were performed by amateurs and professionals alike. The most viral of these involved ‘hand gestures that mimic spooning something into the mouth, then placing both hands atop the head to form dog ears followed by opening and then extending the palms outward like cat claws—a move anyone who has seen the musical Cats will recognize’ (Katz, 2024).

In any economic model that invites all, but only compensates some, there comes a moment where those who labour demand to know how allocation decisions are being made. In The Creator Economy, this information demand is frequently accompanied by an emotionally charged realization that although we might still enjoy being there, there is a high probability that our creativity on platforms will not wind up providing us a path to financial sustainability off them. Here, users tend to gravitate into two camps. Some develop an interest in modifying their behaviours in ways they suspect will better fit the reward systems on platforms on which they circulate—a process that has been dubbed the algorithmic imaginary. 

Others develop a laxer attitude regarding platform rewards, focusing instead on pleasing the other users with whom they come in contact, if only to reap the other sorts of capital that come from being seen as entertainment value. Among the Gen Z subsection of those users, the highest compliment for joking, singing, dancing or otherwise for creatively reworking a politician’s rant about eating pets seems to be, ‘They ate,’ or else ‘Ate and left no crumbs,’ explained by Urban Dictionary (2020) as ‘Popped off in a good way. They killed it. Almost as if they took all the talent and skills and did not leave enough in the world for everyone else.’

From content creators to franchised laughers

To this point, we have attempted to map a trajectory of laughter on social media, starting with a discussion of how designers are encouraged to conceptualize emotion neither as psychological process nor social negotiation, but instead as the quantifiable end-product of technological recognition, classification and reward systems popularly referred to as datafication. We then considered how datafied emotion gets reinjected into user experience via algorithmic operations like personalization, recommendations and content amplification, in the hopes that users will then generate new data to be sold to third parties for profit.

We ended by considering these operations against the stimulus-response loop of the Creator Economy, observing that here, laughter seems to contribute in at least two ways. First, it provides a means for ‘regular’ users to conceive of themselves as contributing value any time they give or receive a laugh. Second, laughter offers one way to emotionally process the transactional aspects of being online. Platforms encourage creativity by presenting it as valuable because it generates data for marketers (this is how platforms explain to users why they engage in practices such as creator monetisation). Yet this creativity often requires enormous amounts of work, which more often than not goes uncompensated. This remains true even when a creator works very hard to build an appreciative audience. It also remains true when a creative act goes viral and generates enormous traffic for a platform.

The political economics of creativity versus ownership has recently been taken up by Herman Mark Schwartz (2022) who argues that today’s knowledge economy ‘has little to do with knowledge per se but rather a lot to do with property rights around knowledge’ (96). As for the owners of those rights, he notes those claiming ‘data is the new oil’ would do well to recall political history of the OPEC cartel, including the force required to perpetuate its myth that oil prices reflected resource scarcity and not monopolistic control. Because it directly references an economic model where the allocation of value turns neither on the scarcity nor on time spent labouring, but instead on a claim of ownership over the largely immaterial resource known as the brand, Schwartz argues that the term franchise economy reflects a more accurate picture of knowledge circulation on and off platforms.

Earlier in our conversation about ‘They’re Eating the Pets,’ we mentioned a number of pieces of content that appeared to be capitalizing on or ‘hijacking’ the debate’s buzz-worthiness to direct attention to unrelated sports and food franchises. A different form of hijacking appears in content that displays visual material owned by film and television companies like Fox News, or uses logos from sports, food or other sorts of franchises without permission. In addition to depriving their owners of licensing fees, content used without legal consent can pose a threat when it appears to endorse a message over which a company has yet to take a stance.

Figure 7: Left: Endorsement from Charli XCX. Right: Kamala Harris Headquarters.

When British citizen Charli XCX uttered the phrase, ‘Kamala is brat,’ the Harris campaign lost no time changing their online site to include the neon green of the Gen Z pop star’s hit album to signal an unofficial sort of co-branding. Likewise, drivers in Phoenix, Arizona who saw billboards reading ‘Eat Less Kittens’ posted by the Republican Party (featured on the left, below) instantly spotted resemblances to well-known billboards from fast food franchise Chick-fil-A (featured on the right.) Here, the question of co-branding gets murky. While it is certainly possible that Chick-fil-A would have formally endorsed Trump at some point, especially given their past affiliation with anti-LGBT organizations, when originally contacted by the press, they refused to comment on the matter. Only later did they share that the design was made without their permission (Moore, 2024). Perhaps they realized that while they certainly had the right to take legal action, by foregoing it they could have the best of both worlds: tacitly gifting their favourites with a trademarked version of goofy cool yet maintaining plausible deniability among the general public.

Figure 8: Left: “Eat Less Kittens” billboard erected by the Arizona Republican party (Moore, 2024) Right: “Eat Mor Chikin” billboard erected by Chick-fil-A (Richards, 2016).

Figure 9: AI imaginings & Lived Experiences. References: Trump and Duck (Rashid, 2024); Libs of Tik Tok post (McDougall, 2024).

Our analysis of this meme cycle would be incomplete without a consideration of content generated with the use of AI technologies, with the biggest enthusiasts of the format coming from the same political camp. A quick tour through Google images turns up at least fifty different versions of a muscled Trump running through mayhem to save the animals, with an occasional image of Harris. Our favourite of these features her nonplussed, preparing to grill a kitten on her barbecue (Rashid 2024).

From platformed market segments to social media publics

Having mapped the way in which platformed laughter moves from interface designers to users-as-creators within the franchising logics of social media platforms, we at last return to the question about TETP raised at the start of this article. How should we respond to the charge that by laughing at jokes ostensibly about the suffering of others, we further enable the mechanisms that allow suffering? 

At this juncture, we revisit two axioms with which we began this article. First, it is impossible to discuss the influence of laughter without considering power. Second, in social media environments, power resides first and foremost with digital platforms: techno-social ecosystems where owners, designers, managers, users, and advertisers interact through infrastructures designed to track, shape and modulate human emotion. Although players and technologies in this ecosystem can have overlapping tasks and sometimes competing ends, at the design level, the playbook tends to read uniformly: on platforms, the point is to keep users incentivized, markets segmenting, and owners profiting.

With these understandings in place, the morphing of a ‘bizarre’ piece of misinformation uttered during a live televised debate into the platformed dynamics of TETP online makes a bit more sense. While building our taxonomy of responses, we quickly saw a sort of economic efficiency running beneath surface irrationalities. With seemingly no affective stimulus going to waste, each iteration of TETP seemed to spawn another strange by plausible market segment to be targeted—or in the parlance of political theorists, fractured publics to be swayed. Within these, individuals, groups and non-human actors (e.g. bots) appeared to be mobilizing different types of humour for different types of ends, making it difficult if not impossible to link the presence or absence of laughter to an allegiance, agenda or stance beyond securing attention, making money or having fun.

While researching this project, we were frequently unable to reverse-engineer why we were algorithmically exposed to certain pieces of content ostensibly relating to TETP, let alone assess the degree to which we should be held responsible (by others, by ourselves) for our reaction to content that clearly did not originate with us, an intended audience. Like contemporary television viewers exposed to an old-fashioned laugh track, we wondered: when embedded in a system that simultaneously reassures me of my freedom and counsels me that everyone fitting my profile responds a certain way, to what degree are my responses my own, and to what degree should it matter?

Among internet scholars, debates on the value of courting laughter in the name of what Hartleyn dubs ‘silly citizenship’ (2012) have been raging for at least a decade. Some see ‘an entry point among personals and groups who have been politically disempowered.’ Others warn of laughter’s capacity to stimulate ‘cynicism, apathy, and general distrust in the political process, undermining digital media’s democratic potentials’ (Davis et al, 2018: 3901). Seeking some empirical answers, Davis et al set out to categorize the function of funny responses on Twitter to two 2016 political gaffes (Donald Trump calling Hillary Clinton a ‘nasty woman’ and Hillary Clinton referring to Trump supporters as a ‘basket of deplorables.’) They were able to categorize two-thirds of these posts as engaged in ‘meaningful political work including expressions of opposition, political identification, and displays of civic support.’ 

As for the remaining one-third of the posts, they were categorized ones in which ‘political content serves playfulness, rather than instances of political messaging delivered humorously’ (2018: 3906). We note here a stark contrast between the specificity with which the researchers define  ‘political content’ (e.g., these tweets, in relation to this topic at this moment) and the ambiguous turn of the phrase, ‘serves playfulness,’ a passive construction that has us wondering what playfulness is, what sort of servicing it requires (and from whom), and whether we are meant to understand the play of yesterday, today, and tomorrow as self-identical. Here we are also reminded of Bourdieu’s discussion of play as a constituent feature of habitus, ‘a kind of practical sense for what is to be done in any given situation—what is called in sport a “feel” for the game’ (Bourdieu, 1998: 25).

Too often, accounts that frame online laughter solely in terms of amplified human agency via hashtags and other platform affordances used by ‘affective publics’ bypass how platforms themselves shape, incentivise, and circulate expressions of emotion online, and increasingly off it. On social media platforms, laughter is not just an immediate, situated (and ethically charged) response; it is also a product of infrastructures that channel and repackage affect. What feels spontaneous is in fact propelled by coordinated, opaque processes of datafication—processes that users may sense and even be alluringly drawn to for the promise of enjoyment yet cannot fully perceive given their transactional nature.

Figure 10: Social Media Publics. Image created by Theresa M. Senft.

To expand this conversion, we offer below a mapping of social media publics. These include older configurations familiar to anyone with a background in political communication, along with two newer categories. The first, taste publics, include groups of users who express interest in or loyalty to specific consumer products, media genres, companies, brands, celebrities, or influencers. Related to these are people drawn together for the purpose of questioning, challenging and/or attacking specific loyalties or interests. The second type we call imitation publics (Zulli & Zulli, 2022). Here, we refer to anyone gathered for the purpose of participating in an activity or challenge that appears to be trending online. Related are those who express concerns related to safety or morality of the trend, or who are drawn to content that voices the view that trend participants are easily manipulated ‘sheep,’ inauthentic ‘clout chasers,’ etc.

Whether one speaks of them positively (as generative markets) or negatively (as degenerative fragments) it makes little sense to consider the political dimensions of social media publics without foregrounding how humans feature in the endgame of platform business models: as data sets surveyed, divided, grouped, and re-grouped in ways designed to yield the greatest financial returns for investors. Given the ferocity with which social media companies guard the proprietary logics driving these processes, celebrations or admonishments that turn solely on questions of human power or social responsibility feel simplistic at best, and victim-blaming at worst. What does agency even look like, in a moment where even the most foundationally human gesture of rejecting the ungraspable by throwing up our hands and laughing meets its digital double in a system designed to extract, package, and market that laughter for its own means and ends?

Conclusion

In this article, we have worked to show how the design of social media platforms stimulates a particular flavour of communication between people and machines by collapsing the ambiguity of human emotion into quantifiable data, using this as fuel to excite, incentivize and increase users’ creative engagement, with an end-game of generating the ‘data driven insights’ that platforms must produce for the advertisers who stimulate cash flow.

After explaining the owner-takes-all nature of this arrangement, we argue that determining what an instance of laughter means on social media requires at a minimum some context as to its circulation through the various landscapes of branding that have substantially reconfigured older ideas about identity, community, and citizenship online. Like a franchise that hopes to expand profit with as little capital investment as necessary, a key feature of what we call franchised laughter is the way it seeks to cobrand (sometimes consensually, other times not) in ways that should not be understood to mean users agree, endorse the same positions, or would even be affiliated in any circumstance. Seen as stimuli, franchised laughter thus becomes a catalyst for the formation of the multiple, disparate, but often overlapping publics illustrated above.

Though incomplete and partial, the conceptual mapping developed in this article affords some explanations of what platformed laughter is doing today, and underscore in some ways what laughter has always done. Long before digital technologies, laughter served as a stimulus that enabled humans to connect, to cohere as groups, to resist power and enforce it. From this perspective, the digital infrastructures that today channel and monetize laughter can be seen less as novel inventions and more as side-effects of a much older evolutionary economy: laughter as connective tissue. What we call franchised laughter thus foregrounds how digital media operationalize an ancient human stimulus for contemporary economic and political ends, opening pathways to new and curious discussions about the interplay between human affect, platform logic, and the ethics of participation in digital publics. At minimum, it reminds us to supplement the old slogan, “If you access something for free online, you are the product” with the caveat, “who at times understandably mistakes themselves for co-owner.”

Mindful that nobody wants a discussion of laughter that ends on an overly sad note, we remain more optimistic than we perhaps should be about the fact that as rigged as social media communication is, there are plenty of times when users—that is, people—decide to buy out, slow down, or simply start playing a new game, or a version of the old game with rules not yet predictable by platforms, because they are not yet understandable as rules. While some of these acts are deliberate, most seem to result when overstimulation tips into boredom.

Of all the moments in TETP, the funniest for many was that the minute Vance urged people to continue what felt like an unstoppable flow of memes, the internet’s interest in making jokes about eating pets seemed to suddenly stop. For some, the flow had stopped long before Trump had finished speaking. ‘When there’s buzzy electoral schadenfreude, meme coins tend to follow,’ quips AI and crypto site Decrypt (Gladwin, 2024), noting how Haitian Cats (hCAT) rose to 86% an hour before the debate, only to lose 90% of its original value by the end. To this news, speculators on Telegram raged ‘This could send to a million easily’ and ‘You guys suck dick’—as good a response as any to news that a laugh has ended as fast it seemed to start.

References

Ahmed, S. (2014) The Cultural Politics of Memory. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Anderson, K.V. (2024)‘“Kamala Harris effectively baited Donald Trump during the debate, drawing out his insecure white masculinity”’, The Conversation, 13 September. Available at: http://theconversation.com/kamala-harris-effectively-baited-donald-trump-during-the-debate-drawing-out-his-insecure-white-masculinity-238850 (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Beauchamp, Z. (2024) ‘“How the GOP became the party of racist memes against Haitian immigrants:” Back in 2016, the alt-right tried to normalize joyful bigotry. It worked’, Vox, 12 September. Available at: https://www.vox.com/politics/371466/trump-haitians-dogs-cats-pets-springfield-alt-right (Accessed: 2 June 2025).

Benzilla2000 (2024) ‘They’re Eating the Dogs – They’re Eating the Cats M4A.m4a’, Benzilla2000, 14 September. Available at: https://soundcloud.com/benzilla2000/theyre-eating-the-dogs-1 (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Boler, M. and Davis, E. (2020) ‘Affect, Media, Movement: Interview with Susanna Paasonen and Zizi Papacharissi’, in Boler, M. and Davis, E. (eds.) Affective Politics of Digital Media: Propaganda, Connections, and Feeling. New York: Routledge, pp. 53–68.

Bourdieu, P. (1998) Practical Reason: On the Theory of Action. Translated by R. Johnson et al. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Boxer, D. and Cortés-Conde, F. (1997) ‘From Bonding to Biting: Conversational Joking and Identity Display’, Journal of Pragmatics, 27(3), pp. 275–294.

Chun, W.H.K. (2017) Updating to Remain the Same: Habitual New Media. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Citton, Y. (2017) The Ecology of Attention. Translated by B. Norman. Cambridge: Polity.

City of Springfield, Ohio – Government (2024) ‘City Commission Meeting, Aug. 27, 2024’, City of Springfield, 28 August. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VL4JXoFcJQI (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Crogan, P. and Kinsley, S. (2012) ‘Paying Attention: Towards a Critique of the Attention Economy’, Culture Machine, 13, pp. 1–29. Available at: https://culturemachine.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/463-1025-1-PB.pdf (Accessed: 4 June 2025).

Davies, C. (1982) ‘Ethnic Jokes, Moral Values and Social Boundaries’, The British Journal of Sociology, 33(3), pp. 383–403.

Davis, J.L., Love, T.P. and Killen, G. (2018) ‘Seriously Funny: The Political Work of Humor on Social Media’, New Media & Society, 20(10), pp. 3898–3916.

Demirtaş, F. (2023) ‘“The Role of Humor in UX Design”: Elevating User Experiences Through Tasteful Levity’, Medium, 22 August. Available at: https://blog.thedexignstudio.com/role-humor-ux-design/ (Accessed: 4 June 2025).

Dynel, M. (2020) ‘On Being Roasted, Toasted and Burned: (Meta)pragmatics of Wendy’s Twitter Humour’, Journal of Pragmatics, 166, pp. 1–14.

ET Online News (2024) ‘Springfield, Ohio becomes meme central as Donald Trump’s debunked pet-eating claim fuels Simpsons parodies’, The Economic Times, 13 September. Available at: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/new-updates/springfield-ohio-becomes-meme-central-as-donald-trumps-debunked-pet-eating-claim-fuels-simpsons-parodies/articleshow/113311534.cms?from=mdr (Accessed: 16 June 2025).

Figura, D. (2024). ‘“Diseases you can get from eating dogs / cats”: Thoughts and prayers to Springfield, Ohio’, footdocdana, 13 September. Available at: https://www.instagram.com/footdocdana/reel/C_1I95pN7f2/ (Accessed: 2 June 2025).

Garsd, J. (2024) ‘“Elections:” The stereotype of immigrants eating dogs and cats is storied — and vitriolic as ever’, NPR, 11 September. Available at: https://www.npr.org/2024/09/11/nx-s1-5108401/donald-trump-debate-eating-dogs-cats-immigrants-false-stereotype (Accessed: 22 April 2025).

Giotta, G. (2017) ‘Sounding Live: An Institutional History of the Television Laugh Track’, Journal of Communication Inquiry, 41(4), pp. 331–348.

Gladwin, R. (2024) ‘Donald Trump Rant About Immigrants “Eating the Pets” Didn’t Do Much for Related Meme Coins’, Decrypt, 11 September. Available at: https://decrypt.co/248902/donald-trump-rant-about-immigrants-eating-the-pets-didnt-do-much-for-con (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Gosh, R. (2024) ‘Kamala Harris’s expressions to Donald Trump’s statements inspire hilarious memes’, India Today, 11 September. Available at: https://www.indiatoday.in/trending-news/story/kamala-harris-facial-expressions-donald-trump-memes-us-presidental-debate-2597618-2024-09-11 (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Hintz, E.A. and Scharp, K.M. (2024) ‘Theory of Communicative (Dis)enfranchisement: Introduction, Explication, and Application’, Journal of Communication, 74(2): 89–100.

Hoffman, R. (2024) ‘“READ”: Harris-Trump presidential debate transcript’, ABC News, 11 September. Available at: https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/harris-trump-presidential-debate-transcript/story?id=113560542 (Accessed: 10 June 2025).

Katz, L. (2024) ‘Trump’s Viral “They’re Eating The Pets” Line Spawns TikTok Dance Craze’, Forbes, 16 September. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/lesliekatz/2024/09/16/trumps-viral-theyre-eating-the-pets-line-spawns-tiktok-dance-craze/ (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Kuang, C. and Fabricant, R. (2019) User Friendly: How the Hidden Rules of Design are Changing the Way We Live, Work, and Play. London: Penguin.

La Fiandra, N. (2024) ‘Kamala Harris taps into meme culture to attract Gen Z voters while Trump stays traditional’, CNYCENTRAL, 24 July 2024. Available at: https://cnycentral.com/news/local/kamala-harris-donald-trump-campaigns-x-charli-xcx-brat-memes-coconut-tree-2024-presidential-election-gen-z-maga-sam-ogborn (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Laineste, L. (2013) ‘Funny or Aggressive? Failed Humour in Internet Comments’, Folklore: Electronic Journal of Folklore, (53), pp. 29–46.

Lanard, N. (2024) ‘“How JD Vance Unleashed the Racist Backlash Against Haitian Immigrants in Springfield, Ohio”: Keep the cat memes flowing’, Mother Jones, 13 September. Available at: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2024/09/how-jd-vance-unleashed-the-racist-backlash-against-haitian-immigrants-in-springfield-ohio/ (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Lanier, J. (2018) Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now. London: The Bodley Head.

MARdStoreCo (2024) ‘Marked Safe from Having My Pet Eaten Today Svg, Debate Svg, Funny svg, Trump svg, png, comedy, humor, Adult humor’, Etsy, 12 September. Available at: https://www.etsy.com/listing/1779201278/marked-safe-from-having-my-peteaten?utm_source=OpenGraph&utm_medium=PageTools&utm_campaign=Share (Accessed: 18 June 2025).

McDougall, A.J. (2024) ‘Shameless JD Vance Doubles Down on Bonkers Cat-Eating Migrants Conspiracy’, Daily Beast, 10 September. Available at: https://www.thedailybeast.com/jd-vance-calls-for-more-anti-migrant-memes-after-spreading-baseless-pet-eating-conspiracy/ (Accessed: 23 April 2025).

McKelvey, F., Langlois, G. and Elmer, G. (2023) ‘“From Disinformation to Speculation”: The Pitch, the Playbook & the Buy-In’, Center for Information, Technology, & Public Life (CITAP), University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill [Preprint]. Available at: https://citap.pubpub.org/pub/for0o4fs. (Accessed: 2 June 2025).

McStay, A. (2018) Emotional AI: The Rise of Emphatic Media. London: SAGE.

McStay, A. (2021) ‘The Consumer Society and Advertising’, in: Long, P., Johnson, B., MacDonald, S., Rogerson Bader, S. and Wall, T. (eds.) Media Studies: Texts, Production, Context. London: Routledge, pp. 424–447.

McStay, A. (2023) Automating Empathy: Decoding Technologies that Gauge Intimate Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Mesa, J. (2024) ‘Trump Supporter Who Blamed Haitians for Stealing Cat Finds Cat in Basement’, Newsweek, 19 September. Available at: https://www.newsweek.com/trump-supporter-blamed-haitians-stealing-cat-finds-pet-1956041 (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Milner, R. (2016) The World Made Meme: Public Conversations and Participatory Media. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Moore, M. (2024) ‘Chick-fil-A Reacts to GOP’s “Eat Less Kittens” Billboards in Arizona’, International Business Times, 12 September. Available at: https://www.ibtimes.com/eat-less-kittens-billboards-arizona-3743060 (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Morreall, J. (2009) Comic Relief: A Comprehensive Philosophy of Humor. Malden, MA: Wiley Blackwell.

Mullan, K. (2022) ‘On the “Dark Side”: Facebook Humour Used for Inclusion and Exclusion’, The European Journal of Humour Research, 10(2), pp. 96–115.

Nickl, B. (2024) ‘Synthetic Laughter: Technologies of Humour Mediation and the Moral Issues of the Laugh Box’, in: Nickl, B. and Rolfe, M. (eds.) Moral Dimensions of Humour: Essays on Humans, Heroes and Monsters. Tampere: Tampere University Press, pp. 160–182.

Nickl, B. and Müller, C.J. (2023) ‘The joke’s on us – how big tech is replicating our laughter online’, The Conversation, 21 September. Available at: https://theconversation.com/the-jokes-on-us-how-big-tech-is-replicating-our-laughter-online-206191 (Accessed: 15 June 2025).

Olmsted, E. (2024) ‘“J.D. Vance’s Pet Memes Request Comes Back to Bite Trump After Debate”: There is no way that Donald Trump and J.D. Vance will live down these pet memes’, The New Republic, 12 September. Available at: https://newrepublic.com/post/185879/jd-vance-donald-trump-debate-memes-migrants-pets (Accessed: 22 April 2025).

Oremus, W. (2024) ‘“How Trump’s Pet-Eating Claim Became a Meme for Right and Left Alike”: each side thinks the joke is on the other’, The Washington Post, 13 September. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2024/09/13/eating-cats-springfield-ohio-meme-x-tiktok-campaign/ (Accessed: 2 June 2025).

Peres, R., Schreier, M., Schweidel, D.A. and Sorescu, A. (2024) ‘The Creator Economy (Editorial): An Introduction and a Call for Scholarly Research’, International Journal of Research in Marketing, 41(3), pp. 403–410.

Phil, M. (2024) ‘Eating the Dogs Memes: 25 Reactions to Trump’s Comment’, ThunderDungeon, 16 September. Available at: https://thunderdungeon.com/2024/09/16/eating-the-dogs-memes/ (Accessed: 16 June 2025).

Plessner, H. (2020) Laughing and Crying: A Study of the Limits of Human Behavior. Translated by J.S. Churchill and M. Grene. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.

Rashid, H. (2024) ‘“MAGA Launches Most Unbelievable Conspiracy Yet—on Migrants Eating Pets”: Republicans are straight up losing their minds with their racist conspiracy theories’, The New Republic, 10 September. Available at: https://newrepublic.com/post/185732/maga-conspiracy-migrants-eating-pets (Accessed: 22 April 2025).

Richards, K. (2016) ‘“Chicken with a Beef:” The Untold Story of Chick-fil-A’s Cow Campaign’, Adweek, 17 June. Available at: https://www.adweek.com/brand-marketing/chicken-beef-untold-story-chick-fil-cow-campaign-171834/ (Accessed: 12 May 2025).

Roush, T. (2024) ‘Springfield Bomb Threats Likely Linked to Right-Wing Conspiracy Targeting Haitians, Mayor Says—As Schools Evacuate Again’, Forbes, 13 September. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/tylerroush/2024/09/13/springfield-evacuates-schools-for-second-day-after-bomb-threat-as-right-wing-conspiracy-theory-targets-haitians/ (Accessed: 12 June 2025).

Scarantino, A. (2016) ‘The Philosophy of Emotions and Its Impact on Affective Science’, in: Feldman Barrett, L., Lewis, M. and Haviland-Jones, J.M. (eds.) Handbook of Emotions. New York: The Guildford Press, pp. 3–48.

Schwartz, H.M. (2022) ‘From Fordism to Franchise: Intellectual Property and Growth Models in the Knowledge Economy’, in: Baccaro, L., Blyth, M. and Pontussen, J. (eds) Diminishing Returns: The New Politics of Growth and Stagnation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 74–97.

Schüll, N. (2014) Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.

Scott, S.K., Lavan, N., Chen, S. and McGettigan, C. (2014) ‘The Social Life of Laughter’, Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 18(12), pp. 618 –620.

Senft, T.M. (2025) ‘Who Cares How Information Feels? A Call for Digital Influence Literacy’, Asian Bioethics Review, 17(3), pp. 477–493.

Shifman, L. and Blondheim, M. (2010) ‘The Medium is The Joke: Online Humor About and By Networked Computers’, New Media & Society, 12(8), pp. 1348–1367.

Shifman, L (2014) Memes in Digital Culture. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Sundén J. and Paasonen, S. (2020) Who’s Laughing Now? Feminist Tactics in Social Media. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Stöcker, C. (2020) ‘How Facebook and Google Accidentally Created a Perfect Ecosystem for Targeted Disinformation’, in: Grimme, C., Preuss, M., Takes, F.W. and Waldherr, A. (eds.) Disinformation in Open Online Media: First International Workshop, MISDOOM 2019. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 129–149.

Swartz, L. (2022). ‘Theorizing the 2017 Blockchain ICO Bubble as a Network Scam’, New Media & Society, 24(7), 1695–1713.

Tannen, D. (2007) Talking Voices: Repetition, Dialogue, and Imagery in Conversational Discourse. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Thomas, M. and Wendling, M. (2024) ‘Trump repeats baseless claim about Haitian immigrants eating pets’, BBC Verify and BBC News, 15 September. Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c77l28myezko (Accessed: 1 June 2025).

Time (1999) ‘The 100 Worst Ideas of the Century’, Time, 14 June, 153(23), p. 36.

Urban Dictionary (2020) ‘Ate and Left no Crumbs’, UD, 17 November. Available at: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Ate%20and%20left%20no%20crumbs (Accessed: 2 June 2025).

Weinberger, M. G. and Gulas, C. S. (2019) ‘The Emergence of a Half-Century of Research on Humour in Advertising: What Have We Learned? What Do We Still Need to Learn?’, International Journal of Advertising, 38(7), pp. 911–956.

WineRev (2024) ‘GNR of Mid-Month: Global Cats, Good News, Cats, Democracy, & Cats’, Daily Kos, 16 October. Available at: https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2024/10/16/2276538/-GNR-of-Mid-Month-Global-Cats-Good-News-Cats-Democracy-amp-Cats (Accessed: 8 June 2025).

Zulli, D. and Zulli, D.J. (2022) ‘Extending the Internet Meme: Conceptualizing Technological Mimesis and Imitation Publics on the TikTok Platform’, New Media & Society, 24(8), pp. 1872–1890.

Notes

[1] As we highlight further below, we approach laughter as “a social emotion, occurring most often in interactions, where it is associated with bonding, agreement, affection, and emotional regulation”, and not, therefore, as an exclusive product of humour (see Scott et al, 2014: 2018).

[2] As a piece of dis/misinformation, the pet eating accusation appears to be a conflation of information from a Springfield speech delivered by a self-described social media influencer (Springfield City Commission, 2024); a Facebook post made in a group for Springfield residents by the neighbor of a woman whose cat went missing (later heavily circulated by conservative politicians including vice-presidential candidate JD Vance (Gladwin, 2024); and news that a U.S. citizen with no connections to Haiti was arrested in a town 170 miles away from Springfield for allegedly killing and hanging her cat (Rashid, 2024.) For their part, the City of Springfield continues to maintain, ‘There have been no credible reports or specific claims of pets being harmed, injured or abused by individuals within the immigrant community’ (Thomas & Wendling, 2024).

[3] The trick of the user-friendly world’, Kuang concludes, ‘is that not only are we addicted, the drug doesn’t have to be bought. The drug lies in our own brains, hardwired there by evolution’ (2019: 257).

Theresa M. Senft is a Visiting Researcher, University of Turku, Finland She has published widely on online communication and social media, including seminal work on camgirls, microcelebrity and health influence literacy. She is a founding member of the Association of Internet Researchers and is currently consulting for the Infodemic Management Unit of the World Health Organization.
Email: theresa.senft@utu.fi

Christopher John Müller is a Senior Lecturer in Media Studies at Macquarie University, Sydney. His research addresses the intersection of technology and emotion and he also translates media theory. He is the author of Prometheanism: Technology, Digital Culture, and Human Obsolescence (2016) and has co-edited Palgrave Handbook of Critical Posthumanism. He is the translator of Günther Anders, The Obsolescence of the Human, Minnesota UP (2025).
Email: chris.muller@mq.edu.au

Benjamin Nickl is a Senior Lecturer in Comparative Literature and Translation Studies at The University of Sydney. His research focuses on mediation technologies such as humour and laughter. He serves as Co-Editor of the Humour as a Human Right article series and is Co-Editor of Moral Dimensions of Humour, an open-access essay collection published by Tampere University Press.
Email: benjamin.nickl@sydney.edu.au

Conflicts of interest
None declared

Funding
None declared

Article history
Article submitted: 18/06/25
Date of original decision: 10/09/25
Revised article submitted: 15/09/25
Article accepted: 15/09/25